Why it was important to make a rough cut?
It was very important to make a rough cut rather that just create our final opening scene as it will allow the group to be able to receive feedback from an audience, which will be our peers. Our rough cut is base on how far we was into the editing process, we was quite far so only a few changes in our mind were needed. Our rough cut includes the sequence, sounds, and changes in editing like filters, credits. From this now we can see if they audience likes, understands and important feels that the product is finished.
Once our rough cut was finished we exporting and uploaded it to YouTube, the rough cut is below, this was purely for the audiences viewing and for them to be able to give us feedback on how we could improve our opening scene.
Once our rough cut was finished we exporting and uploaded it to YouTube, the rough cut is below, this was purely for the audiences viewing and for them to be able to give us feedback on how we could improve our opening scene.
Why audiences feedback is important ?
The audience is a major factor to consider as they are the people that will be watching our final opening scene. So it will be vital for us to be able to obtain feedback from them. The audiences feedback will not be based on there true thoughts about the scene and will not be subject to bias as it will not be criticized openly by members of our own group. This means that all things that need to be improved will be taken into account as it is the audiences true opinion.
The audience is a major factor to consider as they are the people that will be watching our final opening scene. So it will be vital for us to be able to obtain feedback from them. The audiences feedback will not be based on there true thoughts about the scene and will not be subject to bias as it will not be criticized openly by members of our own group. This means that all things that need to be improved will be taken into account as it is the audiences true opinion.
How we got our feedback?
We were given our feedback in two different ways......
Powerpoints and Questions - As a group we made a presentation to show to all the fellow groups of the media course in our class. Within this PowerPoint we included how we got our main ideas for our narrative from each person, the location of our setting and our characters and the main ideas behind them. From this our peers will be able to understand our main inspirations, and ideas behind our opening scene. After we had presented we received questions on the PowerPoint from our class, from which we answered them.
Peer Group Reviewing - After our powerpoints had been presented and while the class had been watching the rough cut, they were given forms to fill out. This forms contained the mark they would be giving us that they had obtained from the mark scheme. Also they contained what went well and what could be improved in our rough cut. These were given to the all the groups in our class and they were collected and given to us to read over and take into account how we could improve our final piece.
Feedback
We received back all of the forms from our peer groups that reviewed our work. From analyzing these results, it is clear that we have a mixture of results.
Mark out of 60 - We obtained a mark of 37-54 from our peers with an average of, 44. This means that we are obtaining a Level 3 Band Rough Cut for our opening scene. By improving our scene and obtaining 4 or more marks we will be able to hit the top band Level 4 for our rough cut.
What Went Well - Our peers thought we did the following well. Good use of camera angles, editing techniques, low key lighting, sounds and effects, characters chosen, conventions,narrative. In addition some groups liked the twist at the end of our scene.
Even Better If - Clearer narrative, some shots made lighter, credits too small, louder soundtrack, antagonists face was lighter at the end.
From looking at these results it is clear that we need to improve some sections of the film, particularly the lighting of some shots as it is clear that the audience cannot see or understand what is happening. From this the audience will be able to understand the narrative. But we cannot make our soundtrack any louder as there is no technique to improve the loudness of the audio. In addition the sound was loud on the Mac that we were using we just think it was a technical issue with the speakers as they were very quiet. Now we understand the issues that need to be fixed and will resolve them to make our final opening scene better for the viewing of our target audience.
We received back all of the forms from our peer groups that reviewed our work. From analyzing these results, it is clear that we have a mixture of results.
Mark out of 60 - We obtained a mark of 37-54 from our peers with an average of, 44. This means that we are obtaining a Level 3 Band Rough Cut for our opening scene. By improving our scene and obtaining 4 or more marks we will be able to hit the top band Level 4 for our rough cut.
What Went Well - Our peers thought we did the following well. Good use of camera angles, editing techniques, low key lighting, sounds and effects, characters chosen, conventions,narrative. In addition some groups liked the twist at the end of our scene.
Even Better If - Clearer narrative, some shots made lighter, credits too small, louder soundtrack, antagonists face was lighter at the end.
From looking at these results it is clear that we need to improve some sections of the film, particularly the lighting of some shots as it is clear that the audience cannot see or understand what is happening. From this the audience will be able to understand the narrative. But we cannot make our soundtrack any louder as there is no technique to improve the loudness of the audio. In addition the sound was loud on the Mac that we were using we just think it was a technical issue with the speakers as they were very quiet. Now we understand the issues that need to be fixed and will resolve them to make our final opening scene better for the viewing of our target audience.